What Were the Border States During Civil War? History
Short answer
The border states during the American Civil War were Delaware, Maryland, Kentucky, Missouri, and later West Virginia. These slaveholding jurisdictions in the Upper South chose not to join the Confederacy, remaining aligned with the federal government throughout the conflict. Their geography and diverse local economies created divided loyalties among their citizens.
Key points
- Delaware, Maryland, Kentucky, and Missouri chose not to join the Confederacy in 1861, and West Virginia separated from Virginia to enter the Union in 1863.
- Every border state shared a geographic boundary with Northern free states, and all except Delaware bordered Confederate territory.
- Enslaved people made up under twenty percent of the total population in each border state according to the 1860 census.
- Irregular guerrilla conflict and divided community loyalties led to bitter internal fighting throughout the region.
Historians exploring what were the border states during civil war identify five specific slave states that remained loyal to the United States: Delaware, Maryland, Kentucky, Missouri, and West Virginia. When hostilities erupted in 1861, eleven southern states severed ties with the Union to establish the Confederate States of America. Four slave states declined to secede during the opening months of the crisis, while the northwestern counties of Virginia organized their own administration and entered the Union as a separate state in 1863.
Geographic positioning placed these jurisdictions directly between the industrial free states and the agrarian Confederacy. Each border state adjoined at least one free state to its north. All of them except Delaware also bordered territory controlled by the Confederacy. This intermediate position generated severe military, political, and social friction. Rail corridors, major river systems, and primary overland roads crisscrossed their territory, making their retention essential for federal war planners.
What Were the Border States During Civil War and Their Demographics?
The social structure of the border region differed sharply from the plantation economies of the Deep South. Enslaved labor existed throughout the Upper South, but the overall proportion of enslaved residents remained far lower than in states like South Carolina or Mississippi. According to the 1860 United States census, enslaved individuals accounted for less than one-fifth of the total population in all five border jurisdictions.
| Border State | Enslaved Population Share (1860) | Bordering Free States | Bordering Confederate States |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delaware | 1.6% | Pennsylvania, New Jersey | None |
| West Virginia | 4.9% | Pennsylvania, Ohio | Virginia |
| Missouri | 9.7% | Iowa, Illinois, Kansas | Arkansas, Tennessee |
| Maryland | 12.7% | Pennsylvania | Virginia |
| Kentucky | 19.5% | Ohio, Indiana, Illinois | Tennessee, Virginia |
These demographic patterns directly influenced political behavior. Regions with fewer enslaved laborers contained strong concentrations of unconditional Unionists. By contrast, river valleys and farming counties dependent on cash crops exhibited deep southern sympathies. The existence of slavery created ideological dilemmas for local leaders who defended federal authority while protecting slave property, recalling the contradictions seen during earlier constitutional debates like those surrounding the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen: 1789 Text.
State Alignments Across the Border Region
Each border state managed the secession crisis through distinct political and military measures. Delaware faced the least internal strife. With an enslaved population below two percent, its legislature voted overwhelmingly against secession in early 1861, keeping the state firmly anchored to the North throughout the conflict.
Maryland occupied an urgent strategic location. It surrounded Washington, D.C., on three sides and controlled the primary rail connections linking the federal capital to northern supply centers. Pro-Confederate rioters attacked Union soldiers in Baltimore in April 1861, prompting President Abraham Lincoln to suspend habeas corpus along military transit corridors. Federal troops secured key cities and communication lines, ensuring the state legislature did not pass an ordinance of secession.
Kentucky attempted to maintain an official stance of armed neutrality during the spring and summer of 1861. Both Union and Confederate recruiters operated quietly within its borders, drawing citizens into opposing armies. Neutrality collapsed in September 1861 when Confederate troops under Leonidas Polk occupied Columbus, Kentucky, prompting Union forces under Ulysses S. Grant to seize Paducah. The state legislature then aligned decisively with the federal government, although a Confederate shadow government operated behind southern battle lines.
Missouri experienced outright civil conflict within its own boundaries. Governor Claiborne Fox Jackson favored secession and assembled pro-southern state militia forces. Federal troops under Nathaniel Lyon drove Jackson and his supporters out of the capital at Jefferson City. Pro-Union delegates formed a provisional state government that directed Missouri's affairs for the rest of the war, while Jackson led a government-in-exile recognized by Richmond.
The Partition of Virginia and Creation of West Virginia
The state of Virginia voted to leave the Union in April 1861, but citizens in the northwestern mountainous counties rejected the decision. Representatives from these western districts assembled at Wheeling, declaring the Richmond secession ordinance void. In a move resembling revolutionary conventions that challenged monarchical authority, such as the Tennis Court Oath: Causes, Events, and Impact, these delegates formed an alternative body known as the Restored Government of Virginia.
Under Francis Pierpont's leadership, this loyal administration governed western areas occupied by federal armies. Because the United States Constitution requires the consent of a state legislature for the creation of a new state from its territory, Pierpont's government granted legal permission for the western counties to organize separately. Congress approved the petition, and West Virginia entered the Union as the fifth border state in June 1863.
Guerrilla Conflict and Divided Loyalties
Conventional armies clashed across Virginia and Maryland, but irregular warfare dominated the border interior. In Missouri, bushwhackers supporting the Confederacy fought bloody skirmishes against pro-Union Jayhawkers and federal cavalry. Civilian property was seized, bridges were burned, and neighborhoods fragmented along political lines. This domestic breakdown generated an environment of suspicion and summary violence resembling European upheavals like the Reign of Terror: Causes, Course, and Downfall.
Western Virginia and East Tennessee suffered comparable guerrilla campaigns. Although Tennessee as a whole joined the Confederacy, its mountainous eastern section remained intensely pro-Union. Guerrillas sabotaged railroad bridges, disrupted communications, and collected intelligence for advancing federal armies. Local figures coordinated escape networks across the rugged landscape. A notable Union guide named Daniel Ellis led hundreds of loyalist recruits, escaped prisoners of war, and refugees through mountain passes into Union-held territory.
The early months of 1861 had seen other Upper South entities, such as North Carolina, Arkansas, Tennessee, and Virginia, classified as border states while they debated their path. Once federal calls for troops followed the firing on Fort Sumter, those four states opted for secession. Delaware, Maryland, Kentucky, Missouri, and West Virginia held their positions, providing the Union with vast manpower reserves, industrial facilities in St. Louis and Baltimore, and control over the strategic Ohio River.
Questions people also ask
Why were they called border states in the Civil War?
They were called border states because they sat directly on the geographic boundary between the northern free states and the Confederate slave states, retaining slavery while remaining inside the Union.
Did border states allow slavery during the war?
Yes, all five border states were slave states, though enslaved people made up a much smaller fraction of their populations compared to the Deep South.
Why did West Virginia become a border state?
West Virginia separated from Virginia after rejecting Richmond's secession ordinance, forming a pro-Union administration that was admitted as a new state in 1863.
Related pages
- Sherman's March to the Sea: Route and Impact
Sherman's March to the Sea was a Union campaign across Georgia from Atlanta to Savannah, conducted from November 15 to December 21, 1864. It damaged Confederate infrastructure and supplies while showing that Union forces could operate deep in the South without relying on a continuous rail link to their base.
- Battle of Fort Sumter: How the Civil War Began
The Battle of Fort Sumter marked the start of the American Civil War. On April 12, 1861, Confederate artillery fired on the Union fort in Charleston Harbor, and Major Robert Anderson surrendered after 34 hours. The attack led both sides to call for volunteers and turned a political crisis into open war.
- What Was the Emancipation Proclamation 1863?
The Emancipation Proclamation was an executive order issued by President Abraham Lincoln on January 1, 1863, declaring that all enslaved individuals held in Confederate territory in active rebellion were legally free. Issued under presidential war powers, the directive transformed the Civil War by coupling the preservation of the Union with the destruction of slavery. It also authorized the formal recruitment and military service of Black soldiers and sailors into federal armed forces.
- Causes of the American Civil War: Origins and Breakdown
The American Civil War was caused primarily by unresolved disputes over the preservation and territorial expansion of slavery. The 1860 election of Abraham Lincoln led eleven Southern slaveholding states to secede and organize the Confederate States of America. Military conflict began on April 12, 1861, when Confederate forces bombarded the federal garrison at Fort Sumter.
- The Surrender at Appomattox Court House: End of the War
On April 9, 1865, General Robert E. Lee surrendered the Confederate Army of Northern Virginia to Lieutenant General Ulysses S. Grant in Appomattox County, Virginia. The capitulation followed an exhaustive week-long retreat from Petersburg and Richmond after Union forces encircled the remaining Confederate lines. Grant granted generous parole conditions that averted protracted guerrilla fighting and established the template for all subsequent Confederate surrenders.
- Seljuk Architecture: Forms, Materials, and Legacy
Seljuk architecture is the building tradition associated with Seljuk rule from the 11th to the 13th centuries. It combined regional construction practices with distinctive forms such as the four-iwan mosque plan, domed spaces, monumental portals, and, especially in Anatolia, richly carved stone.
How this page was prepared
Before writing, the topic was researched in the sources below. The page then passed automatic quality checks.